The era of third-party cookies is coming to an end. Following Safari’s lead, Google is preparing to stop using them. This news has a major impact on digital marketing and online advertising, whatever platform you use.
Why does the end of third-party cookies matter for marketers?
The coming disappearance of third-party cookies could lead to significant revenue losses for marketers who aren’t prepared for the change. Third-party cookies have long been a valuable tool for collecting user data and, as a result, targeting ads. With them gone, brands will have to find new ways to reach their audiences.
In this article, our goal is to look closely at the consequences of this change. We’ll discuss the steps marketers can take to adapt to this new reality. From understanding what a third-party cookie and a first-party cookie are, to how they differ and the alternative solutions for ad targeting, we’ll cover everything you need to navigate this changing landscape.
What is a third-party cookie?
In today’s digital ecosystem, third-party cookies are everywhere and play a crucial role in marketing strategies. These small text files, distinct from first-party cookies and usually placed on your device by an entity other than the website you’re visiting, power a wide range of operations focused on user tracking and ad targeting.
The role of third-party cookies
Third-party cookies serve several purposes that improve the user experience and help marketers reach their goals. Here are some of their main uses:
- Data collection: They are essential for collecting information about users’ browsing habits.
- Ad targeting: With this data, brands can show personalised ads based on each user’s online behaviour.
- Retargeting: Third-party cookies also make it possible to track users who visited a site without buying, so the product or service can be shown to them again while they browse other sites.
How they work with first-party cookies
Third-party cookies don’t work in isolation; they often interact with first-party cookies to refine the user experience:
- First-party cookies: Created and stored by the website you are visiting directly, they mainly remember your preferences, such as language or regional settings, and make interactions like managing your shopping cart easier.
- Interaction: When a user returns to a website, first-party cookies can use the information collected by third-party cookies to personalise the experience further, for example by showing product recommendations based on browsing history.
Privacy implications
The fundamental difference between third-party and first-party cookies lies in where the data comes from and how it’s used:
- Managed by the site you visit: First-party cookies are managed by the site you are on, which limits their reach to that domain alone.
- Cross-site collection: Third-party cookies, by contrast, can track your activity across different websites, which raises important questions about privacy and user consent.
A concrete example
Take an e-commerce platform:
1. A first-party cookie saves your preferred size to make future purchases easier.
2. At the same time, a third-party cookie from an ad agency tracks your interest in certain product categories and uses that information to show relevant ads when you visit other sites.
Clearly, the planned end of third-party cookies will require a major rethink of marketing strategies. Marketers need to consider how to make effective use of first-party cookies while respecting user privacy. It also becomes essential to identify and adopt viable alternatives that keep ad targeting effective without compromising ethical or legal standards.
What is a first-party cookie?
Now let’s look at what a first-party cookie is. It’s a text file placed on your device by the website you are visiting. It has several essential functions that help improve your online experience.
Key functions of first-party cookies
- Collecting information: First-party cookies collect valuable information about how you interact with the site. They can remember your preferences, such as the language you chose or the items you added to your shopping cart.
- Improving the user experience: These cookies let the website offer you a more personalised experience. For example, they can remember your login details, so you don’t have to enter your username and password every time you visit.
- Analysing user behaviour: First-party cookies also help website owners understand how users move around their site. This can help identify areas that need improvement and provide a better service to users.
It’s worth noting that first-party cookies are generally seen as less intrusive than third-party cookies. Why? Because they are directly tied to the site you’re visiting. It’s the website itself that places these cookies on your device, not a third party.
Benefits for users
First-party cookies offer users several benefits. They make it possible to:
- Save preferences: Thanks to these cookies, a website can remember your preferences and offer you a personalised experience. For example, if you choose a specific language on your first visit, the site will remember your choice through a first-party cookie and show content in that language on later visits.
- Make the site easier to use: First-party cookies also make the site easier to use by remembering relevant information. For example, if you add items to your cart but don’t complete your purchase right away, the first-party cookie keeps those items in your cart for a set period.
- Improve site performance: Finally, these cookies let website owners assess how their site is performing. They can use the data collected to improve the site’s functionality and efficiency.
However, it’s important for marketers to understand how first-party cookies differ from third-party cookies and how they can use each to improve their marketing strategies.
What are the differences between third-party and first-party cookies?
The web browsing experience relies heavily on cookies, small text files that play quite distinct, fundamental roles. Understanding the differences between third-party and first-party cookies is essential to grasp their impact on privacy and marketing strategy.
First-party cookies: securing the user experience
- Created and managed by the site you visit: First-party cookies are generated directly by the domain you are browsing. Their management stays under the exclusive control of the original site.
- Optimising interaction with the site: These cookies are meant to improve your user experience. They remember your preferences, your login details or the contents of your cart during online shopping sessions.
- Respect for privacy: Data collection is limited to your interaction with that site, which makes them less likely to intrude on privacy than third-party cookies.
Third-party cookies: an advertising tool under scrutiny
- Set by external domains: Unlike first-party cookies, third-party cookies are set by entities other than the website you originally visit. These can be ad networks or analytics services.
- Tracking user behaviour: The main goal here is cross-site tracking of browsing habits to build precise advertising profiles. This lets brands refine their targeting across different websites.
- Privacy concerns: The ability of third-party cookies to collect information without the user’s full awareness or explicit consent raises important ethical and legal questions.
The differences between these two types of cookies largely shape today’s digital ecosystem and directly influence marketing strategies. With the regulatory and technological changes under way, it’s vital for digital marketers to anticipate these shifts and adapt their approach.
As we keep navigating this fast-changing landscape, it’s worth looking at the emerging alternatives that respect privacy while still offering effective ways to engage customers.
How do third-party cookies benefit brands?
Third-party cookies play a leading role in brands’ digital strategies. They allow a detailed analysis of the customer journey across different websites, making it easier to personalise communication and optimise ad targeting.
Tracking users across sites
Third-party cookies are essential for following users as they browse the web. They record the sites visited, the time spent on each page and other actions taken. This data gives brands an overall view of consumer behaviour, letting them show ads that match users’ interests. Ad campaigns become more relevant, increasing click-through rates and potentially conversions.
Analysing trends and behaviour
By examining the browsing habits collected by third-party cookies, brands can spot emerging trends and adjust their strategy accordingly. The insights gained help refine market segmentation and build personalised content strategies that resonate with specific audiences.
Personalising the user experience
Armed with precise information about their customers, brands can personalise the experience on their own digital platforms. Whether through product recommendations or changes to site navigation, these adjustments based on individual behaviour help build brand loyalty and improve customer satisfaction.
Sophisticated ad targeting
With the data collected by third-party cookies, advertisers can refine their retargeting or remarketing techniques. This means users who visited certain pages or showed interest in certain products will be retargeted with specific ads designed to prompt action.
Third-party cookies are therefore powerful tools for fine-tuning a company’s marketing positioning. They support a data-driven approach that maximises advertising effectiveness while offering a richer, more personalised user experience. However, with the digital landscape about to change and third-party cookies gradually disappearing, it’s crucial for marketers to explore and master new ways of reaching their target audience.
When will third-party cookies disappear?
Google Chrome is following Firefox and Safari in phasing out third-party cookies by the end of 2024. Google’s first plans aimed to remove these cookies in early 2022, before pushing the deadline to the end of 2023. However, given the challenges of this transition, Google opted for a further delay, which gives the market time to experiment with new methods and build alternative strategies.
This change is hugely important when you consider that Chrome drives a significant share of web traffic. With 65.86% of the global browser market in 2022, Chrome plays a leading role in the digital ecosystem.
In its effort to meet growing expectations around data privacy, Google has announced its intention to stop using individual identifiers across its products altogether. Instead, the company plans to rely on application programming interfaces (APIs) that respect user privacy while still delivering relevant results to advertisers and publishers.
With these changes around the corner, the marketing landscape is set to transform. Marketers need to recognise that:
- The planned end of third-party cookies will bring a significant overhaul of online advertising practices.
- Brands should actively explore and test alternatives such as Google’s Privacy Sandbox and Topics API.
- A thorough understanding of regulations such as the GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation) becomes essential to navigate this new privacy-focused environment.
Professionals must prepare for this new era, where traditional practices give way to innovative, privacy-respecting solutions.
Why are third-party cookies disappearing?
Third-party cookies are currently being seriously called into question, mainly because of two factors: data privacy and changing regulations. Let’s look at the key drivers behind their gradual phase-out.
The impact of data privacy
Growing awareness of online privacy has shone a light on invasive tracking practices. Users are increasingly concerned that their online activity is being tracked and analysed by third parties without their explicit consent. This growing demand for privacy has pushed browser developers like Chrome, which holds a large share of the market, to review their policies and move toward less intrusive solutions.
Changing regulations
Data protection laws such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the European Union and the California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA) in the United States have strengthened consumers’ rights over their personal data. These regulations require more transparency and give users more control over how their information is collected and used. Companies must now obtain explicit consent before they can track a user’s online behaviour, which makes using third-party cookies much more complex.
These changes mark a turning point in how personal data is handled online. Since advertisers and digital marketers relied heavily on these cookies to target and retarget consumers effectively, they now face a major challenge: finding privacy-friendly alternatives that meet users’ new expectations while keeping marketing effective.
The planned end of third-party cookies is therefore not just a reaction to privacy concerns or regulatory requirements, but also a response to growing demand for an internet that respects its users more. The shift to a new paradigm will require innovation and adaptation, topics we’ll cover in the rest of this article.
The post-cookie landscape: what are the challenges and opportunities for marketers?
The removal of third-party cookies by the leading browsers is shaking up the online marketing ecosystem. Marketers and advertisers face a big challenge: adapting their strategies to a world without these valuable tracking tools. Without third-party cookies, companies risk significant revenue losses, while ad spend could rise in the search for effective alternatives.
Impact on digital marketing
- Measuring campaign effectiveness: Without third-party cookies, assessing the success of marketing actions becomes more complex. Metrics such as conversion rate and return on investment (ROI) require more sophisticated tracking methods or a complete rethink.
- Retargeting users: Ad retargeting relies heavily on data collected by third-party cookies. Without them, reaching consumers again after they’ve shown interest in a product or service calls for an innovative approach.
- Personalisation: Personalising user experiences, key to building loyalty and increasing engagement, is compromised without the wealth of information third-party cookies provided.
Finding alternative solutions
- Investing in emerging technologies: To make up for these losses, a close look at new technologies is essential. Adopting tools like Privacy Sandbox or Topics API early can provide a competitive advantage.
- Making the most of first-party data: Data collected directly from consumers becomes even more important. Building a solid base of first-party data is essential to support targeted marketing.
- Diversifying ad channels: Look beyond behavioural targeting by strengthening organic SEO, contextual marketing and email marketing, to build a strong presence on several fronts.
Brands therefore need to navigate this uncertain landscape with agility and creativity. Relying on cross-disciplinary collaboration between data experts, content creators and digital strategists will be crucial to design impactful campaigns despite the challenges.
How to adapt to a world without third-party cookies?
As the digital marketing landscape changes, marketers have to adapt. In this context, consent-based marketing is becoming more important.
Consent-based marketing
Consent-based marketing means getting users’ explicit permission before collecting their data. This approach respects user privacy and strengthens their trust in the brand. Companies can use strategies such as offering users an incentive to share their information, or explaining clearly how their data will be used to improve their experience.
Diversifying data collection methods
Beyond consent, diversifying data collection methods is essential for marketers. This can include sources such as:
- Direct declared data: Information the user provides voluntarily, for example when filling in a form on a website.
- Behavioural data: Data gathered by observing how users interact with your website or app.
- Location data: Information that shows where your users are physically located.
These different forms of data collection give brands a more complete and accurate picture of their target audience.
Using artificial intelligence for targeting
Artificial intelligence (AI) also offers huge opportunities for ad targeting. With sophisticated algorithms, AI can analyse and interpret large amounts of data to identify trends and behaviour patterns. This helps marketers understand their audience better and personalise their messages accordingly.
In a world without third-party cookies, marketers therefore need a more ethical and transparent approach to data collection. By diversifying their data collection methods and using technologies such as AI, they can keep offering users a personalised experience while respecting their privacy.
The future of ad targeting without third-party cookies
In a constantly changing world where online advertising has become essential to business success, the announced end of third-party cookies is a major challenge. Advertisers now need to consider new ways to reach their audience effectively.
One of these could well be contextual targeting. With this approach, ads are shown based on the content of the page the user is viewing, rather than their past browsing behaviour. So if a user is reading an article about Italian cooking, they might see ads for Italian cookbooks, cooking classes or nearby Italian restaurants.
This type of targeting has several advantages:
- It respects user privacy: Unlike third-party cookies, contextual targeting doesn’t follow users around the web. It relies only on the content they choose to view.
- It offers a more relevant experience: Ads are directly related to the content the user is reading. This increases the chance they’ll find the ad interesting and relevant.
- It complies with regulations: Contextual targeting doesn’t require users’ explicit consent, which keeps it compliant with personal data protection rules.
Despite these advantages, contextual targeting can’t do everything third-party cookies currently do. For example, it doesn’t let advertisers follow users across several websites and gather detailed information about their browsing behaviour.
Given this limitation, advertisers will need to find new ways to target their audience. One possibility is closer collaboration between publishers and advertisers to share user data while complying with current regulations. This could include exchanging anonymised or aggregated data, or building audience profiles based on user behaviour on a specific site.
Advertisers could also explore other methods, such as:
- Influencer marketing: Working with influencers who have a specific audience can be an effective way to target precise demographic groups.
- Consent-based marketing: By explicitly asking users for permission to collect and use their data, companies can build a relationship of trust with their customers while gaining valuable information for targeting.
In this new environment without third-party cookies, the key to success for advertisers will be their ability to adapt and innovate. While the end of third-party cookies is certainly a challenge, it also gives brands the opportunity to rethink their strategies and get closer to their audiences.
Conclusion
The disappearance of third-party cookies marks a major turning point in digital marketing. Although this change brings many challenges, it also paves the way for an approach that respects privacy more.
- Marketers now need to rethink how they collect and use data. They have to consider other ways of targeting their audience without relying on third-party cookies.
- Using first-party data, search engine optimisation (SEO), contextual advertising and email marketing are some of the alternatives gaining importance.
- Collaboration between publishers and advertisers could also intensify, allowing more precise audience targeting.
Rather than seeing this change as a constraint, marketers can see it as an opportunity. By anticipating it and adopting alternative strategies, they can not only keep reaching their audience effectively, but also strengthen consumer trust when it comes to respecting their privacy.
